This is our full menu listed below. You can also download a printable PDF version at this link. Please browse the selections below and check out some of the menu packages as well, but please feel free to mix and match as you like! If there’s something you don’t see here ask and we are happy to do our best to accommodate. 


·         Sesame Seared Ahi Tuna on Wonton Chip with Creamy Wasabi and Sweet Soy Sauce
·         Smoked Fish Dip on a Homemade Spicy Chip
·         Grilled Mango Shrimp
·         Coconut Shrimp with Orange Horseradish Marmalade
·         Classic Shrimp Cocktail
·         Jumbo Lump Crab in Coconut Mango sauce
·         Snapper Ceviche
·         Mini Crab Cakes
·         Conch Fritters with Bimini sauce
·         Jerk Grilled Scallops
·         Shrimp and Corn Salsa in an edible cup

·         Thai Peanut Chicken Satay
·         Tequila Lime Chicken Satay
·         Chicken Potstickers
·         Roast Beef Carpaccio Crostini
·         Sweet and Sour Meatballs
·         Mini Sliders
·         Mini Cuban Sandwiches
·         Macadamia Nut Encrusted Chicken Bites

·         Brie & Raspberry in a Puff Pastry
·         Mozzarella Tomato Pesto Crostini
·         Parmesan Artichoke Bites
·         Spinach and Feta Triangles
·         Sundried Tomato Hummus and Homemade Spiced Chips
·         Guacamole and Homemade Spiced Chips
·         Spring Rolls
·         Fruit and Cheese Skewers
·         Vegetarian Pot Stickers

·         Caribbean Salad with Mixed Greens Strawberries and Mangos and Honey Champagne Vinaigrette
·         Traditional Caesar
·         Greek Salad with Key lime vinaigrette, Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Olives and Feta Cheese
·         Roasted Corn and Hearts of Palm
·         Baby Spinach with Candied Walnuts, Strawberries, Mandarin Oranges and Blue Cheese
·         Mozzarella Tomato Caprese with Polenta Croutons

·         Cuban Bread
·         Garlic Bread
·         Jalapeño Corn Bread


·         Matecumbe Chicken with Artichokes, Capers, Sundried Tomatoes, Red Peppers in Garlic Cream Sauce
·         Tequila Lime Chicken
·         Jamaican Jerk Chicken
·         Chicken Saltimbocca
·         Chicken Parmesan
·         Grilled Chicken with Pineapple salsa
·         Chicken Tropical, Apricot and Mango in an Herb Sauce topped with Coconut

·         Marinated Flank Steak
·         Filet Mignon
·         Mojo Pulled Pork
·         Bacon Wrapped Pork Tenderloin
·         Chicken & Steak Fajitas

·         Onion Crusted Yellowtail or Mahi with Key Lime Chardonnay
·         Macadamia Crusted Yellowtail
·         Grilled Yellowtail or Mahi with Pineapple Salsa
·         Shrimp & Clams in Garlic Lemon
·         Sesame Sear Tuna Steak with Cucumber Salad
·         Island Supreme Pasta with Shrimp, Scallops and Clams in a light Key Lime sauce
·         Blackened Mahi Tacos
·         Islamorada Lobster Chunks in Key Lime Sauce
·         Macadamia Shrimp with Mango Salsa


·         Garlic Roasted New Potatoes
·         Garlic and Parmesan Mashed Potatoes
·         Potatoes Del Monaco (Cheesy Potatoes)
·         Maple Glazed Sweet Potatoes

·         Coconut Jasmine Rice
·         Tropical Rice w/ Cilantro and Pineapple
·         Saffron Rice
·         White Rice and Black Beans
·         Herbed Orzo
·         Herbed Orzo topped with Grilled Vegetables and Feta Cheese

·         Mozzarella Tomato Pasta Salad
·         Penne Marinara
·         Farfalle Primavera
·         Farfalle in Key Lime Cream Sauce
·         Penne Alfredo
·         Mac & Cheese

·         Corn Soufflé
·         Grilled Zucchini, Yellow Squash and Roasted Red Peppers
·         Roasted Asparagus with Red Peppers
·         Maple Glazed Baby Carrots
·         Garlic Steamed Broccoli
·         Steamed Vegetable Medley
·         Island Coleslaw with Pineapple
·         Spicy Island Baked Beans
·         Sweet Plantains
·         Grilled Rum Pineapple topped with Toasted Coconut

Wedding Cakes

You can select the design of your choice for your wedding cake. Find a picture of how you want the cake to look and our talented cake designer and baker will replicate the design for you. These are the cake flavors to choose from.

·         Key Lime
·         Lemon
·         Orange Sunset
·         Strawberry Short Cake
·         Vanilla
·         Chocolate
·         Marble
·         Captain Morgan Rum
·         Almond Amaretto
·         Italian Cream & Espresso


·         Key Lime Pies
·         Mini Key Lime Tarts
·         Cupcakes or Mini Cupcakes
·         Chocolate Truffles
·         Chocolate Mousse
·         Strawberry Shortcake
·         Cannoli’s

Sample Wedding Menus

Below is a selection of our most popular wedding menus with the pricing to give you some ideas for your menu!

Jamaican Jerk Dinner
Jamaican Jerk Spiced Grilled Chicken with Caribbean Salad, Jalapeño Corn Bread, White Rice and Black Beans, Marinated Grilled Vegetables. Cost: $42.00 per person.

BBQ Dinner
Mojo Pulled Pork with Homemade BBQ sauce and Grilled Chicken Breast with Roasted Corn & Hearts of Palm Salad, Fresh Baked Bread, Corn Soufflé, Baked Beans and Island Pineapple Slaw. Cost: $42.00 Per person.

Islamorada Dinner
Island Snapper with Key Lime Sauce, Marinated Flank Steak, Garlic Mashed Potatoes, Steamed Vegetable Medley, Caribbean Salad, and Fresh Baked Bread. Cost: $55.00 per person

Sunset Dinner
Maryland Style Crab Cake with Red Pepper Sauce, Bacon Wrapped Pork Tenderloin, Baby Spinach Salad, Fresh Baked Bread, Grilled Vegetable Medley, and Herbed orzo. Cost: $50.00 per person.

Surf & Turf Dinner
Grilled Filet Mignon & Grilled Mango Shrimp with Caribbean Salad, Fresh Baked Bread, Roasted Asparagus, and Garlic Roasted New Potatoes. Cost: $65.00 per person

Pasta Stations
A Wedding favorite! Live Chef Station. Each guest creates their own unique pasta dish. Either Penne or Tortellini with choice of Shrimp, Scallops, Chicken, Sausage, Mushrooms, Tomatoes, Spinach, Broccoli, Onions, Garlic, Artichokes and Choice of Sauces: White Wine, Pesto, Alfredo, Marinara, with Salad and Fresh Baked Bread.
Cost: $47.00/person · Chef Fees: $200.00 per chef

  • These prices are bases on a buffet/stations style dinner, plated dinners are an additional charge.

Rehearsal Dinners

All of our themed rehearsal dinner menus are $25.00 per person if you are already utilizing Caribbean Catering for your wedding. Otherwise, rehearsal only dinners are $35 per person.

Italian Themed Dinner
Caesar Salad, Garlic Bread, Chicken Parmesan, Penne Marinara with Meatballs and Garlic Steamed Broccoli

Asian Themed Dinner
Rice Noodle Salad, Chicken Potstickers, Sesame Seared Ahi Tuna, Thai Peanut Chicken and Stir Fried Rice and Veggies

Cuban Themed Dinner
Mojo Pulled Pork, Garlic Lime Grilled Chicken, Tomato and Avocado Salad, White Rice and Black Beans  

Mexican Themed Dinner
Chicken Enchiladas and Build your own blacked Mahi Mahi tacos, with Soft Flour Tortillas or Hard Taco Shells, and all the fixings: Fresh Tomato, Guacamole, Chopped Onion, Chipotle Sour Cream, Lettuce, Mexican Cheese Blend, Traditional Salsa, Corn and Black Bean Salsa, Jalapeños and Hot Sauce

BBQ Themed Dinner
BBQ Pulled Pork, Grilled Chicken with homemade BBQ sauce, Island Pineapple Slaw, Mozzarella Tomato Pasta Salad and Spicy Island Baked Beans